Oak And Elephant Lab
Our ApproachProgramsFAQ'sArticlesAbout Us
Start Now
Start Now
Back to Blog
Purpose
September 3, 20268 min

We Were Never Meant to Figure It All Out Alone

K

Ki Siadatan

Founder & Mentor

We Were Never Meant to Figure It All Out Alone

There is an interesting contradiction in the way we prepare young people for the future. We spend years giving them structure, schedules, teachers, coaches, assignments, deadlines, and clearly defined measures of progress, and then, somewhere between the final years of high school and the first several years of a career, we begin asking them to make some of the most consequential decisions of their lives.

Where should I go to college? What should I study? What kind of work do I want to do? Where do I want to live? What relationships matter to me? What does success look like? What happens if the path I chose turns out to be the wrong one? And beneath all of those questions is a much bigger one that doesn't fit neatly onto an application or résumé: Who am I becoming?

At precisely the time when those questions become more complicated, we often assume that independence means young people should be able to figure them out largely on their own. I have never been convinced that makes much sense.

Not because young people are incapable of making good decisions for themselves. In fact, the opposite is much closer to what I believe. These years are filled with an extraordinary capacity for curiosity, growth, experimentation, and change. But independence and isolation are two very different things, and learning to make your own decisions does not mean there is no value in having thoughtful people walking alongside you while you learn how to make them.

That belief is one of the reasons I created Oak & Elephant Lab.

Mentorship is not about handing someone a map

When I think about the people who have had the greatest influence on my own life, very few of them simply told me what to do. The ones I remember were the people who helped me see something differently, asked a question I hadn't considered, shared an experience that gave me perspective, challenged an assumption I was carrying, or occasionally told me something I didn't particularly want to hear but probably needed to.

That, to me, is mentorship at its best. It isn't about having someone else make your decisions. It is about developing the judgment and confidence to make better decisions for yourself.

There is considerable research behind the importance of relationships like these. In its extensive review of the science of mentorship, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine found that effective mentoring is associated with positive outcomes across academic achievement, persistence, degree attainment, career success, career satisfaction, and career commitment. Just as importantly, the National Academies emphasized that effective mentorship includes both career support and psychosocial support, recognizing that development is not simply about acquiring the skills necessary to perform a job.

I think that distinction is particularly important when we talk about young people.

We understandably devote enormous attention to preparing them for the next measurable milestone. In high school, that may mean getting into college. In college, it becomes choosing a major, finding an internship, graduating, and landing the first job. A few years later, attention shifts toward promotions, income, professional networks, and advancement. None of those things are unimportant, but they represent only one part of what someone is navigating during these years.

At the same time, young people are developing relationships, experiencing failure and rejection, becoming financially independent, reconsidering beliefs they may have inherited, deciding which friendships they want to carry forward, learning how to handle conflict, discovering what they value, and beginning to decide how much of their identity they want tied to achievement. They are also encountering the inevitable moments when the life they imagined at 17, 20, or 23 no longer quite fits the person they are becoming.

There isn't a class for most of that.

Sometimes what we need is perspective

One of the most valuable things a mentor can offer isn't an answer, but perspective. Someone who has traveled a little farther can often recognize that a decision that feels enormous today may look very different five years from now, while something that seems relatively unimportant may ultimately shape a life in ways that aren't immediately obvious.

The research on mentorship reflects this broader role. The National Academies describes mentorship as a relationship that supports both personal and professional growth and can include role modeling, advising, career guidance, psychosocial support, and helping people develop broader networks of mentors and peers. It also emphasizes that good mentoring is collaborative and responsive to the needs, goals, interests, and priorities of the person being mentored.

That last point is fundamental to how I think about this work. A mentor shouldn't be creating a younger version of themselves. The purpose isn't to say, “Here is the path I took, so you should take it too.” If anything, experience should make us humble enough to recognize that the world a 20-year-old is entering today is not the world I entered at 20.

The value of experience is not that it gives us all the answers. It is that, over time, we have accumulated mistakes, relationships, successes, disappointments, unexpected turns, and moments of clarity that can help us ask better questions.

Those questions matter.

What actually makes you happy? What do you value when nobody else is watching? How much of your definition of success is really yours? Who are the people you want around you? What happens when the plan doesn't work? What kind of leader do you want to become before anyone gives you a title? What are you willing to sacrifice for ambition, and perhaps more importantly, what aren't you willing to sacrifice?

These aren't questions someone answers once and files away. I am still asking some of them myself, and I suspect I always will.

Our circles matter too

There is another part of mentorship that I believe deserves more attention, particularly during these formative years. Growth doesn't happen only through a relationship with a mentor. It also happens when our circles become larger.

Most of us naturally build relationships with people who occupy the same environments we do. Our friends attend the same school, live in the same dorm, participate in the same activities, work in the same industry, or share many of the same experiences. Those relationships can be incredibly meaningful, but they can also mean that much of the advice and perspective we encounter comes from people looking at life from roughly the same vantage point.

Good mentoring can help expand that world.

This is one reason the National Academies' work is interesting to me. Its review notes that effective mentorship can include helping mentees develop supportive networks of additional mentors and peers, rather than assuming one mentor should somehow provide everything a person needs.

It is also one of the reasons we are building Oak & Elephant around both 1:1 mentoring and cohorts. There is tremendous value in having someone give you their undivided attention and help you think through your own experiences, decisions, and questions. There is a different kind of value in sitting with peers outside your normal social circle, hearing how they see the world, discovering that someone else is wrestling with a question you thought was uniquely yours, and beginning to build relationships with people you might never otherwise have met.

We need both kinds of connection.

Why Oak & Elephant

I have spent much of my professional life leading people, building teams, developing emerging leaders, and watching people navigate change. I have also spent decades working with young people through schools, community organizations, Rotary, Rotaract, Interact, volunteer work, and countless informal mentoring relationships. Somewhere along the way, I began to recognize that the conversations I found most meaningful were rarely about how someone could become more impressive on paper.

They were about life.

They were conversations about choosing a direction when several paths looked possible, recovering when something didn't work, navigating relationships, developing confidence without losing humility, deciding what kind of leader to become, figuring out what success actually means, and learning that changing your mind isn't always evidence that you made a mistake. Sometimes it is evidence that you learned something.

Those experiences eventually helped shape the philosophy behind Oak & Elephant Lab and the six areas we explore: Roots, Strength, Wisdom, Relationships, Leadership, and Legacy.

The oak represents something I think our achievement-oriented culture sometimes encourages young people to overlook. Before there is visible growth, there are roots. The things that ultimately allow us to stand through storms are often being developed long before anyone else can see them: character, values, resilience, self-awareness, relationships, and a sense of who we are.

The elephant represents a different idea. Wisdom accumulates through experience, memory, relationships, and community, and there is value in learning from those who have traveled farther while still choosing your own path.

Put those ideas together and you get much of what I believe mentorship should be.

Oak & Elephant isn't about giving young people a roadmap for how to live their lives, because I don't believe such a roadmap exists. It is about creating the relationships, conversations, experiences, and space that help them understand themselves more deeply, encounter perspectives beyond their own, make more thoughtful decisions, learn from the decisions that don't work, and gradually become more confident in choosing the life they want to build.

We spend a great deal of time preparing young people to make a living. I think we should spend at least as much time helping them think about how they want to live.

They shouldn't have to figure all of that out alone.

Grow Deep. Walk Wisely. Live with Purpose.

Share
BEGIN THE ACCELERATOR

Ready to grow deep before you grow tall?

Start Now

Stay in the loop

support@oakandelephantlab.com
Pages
HomeOur ApproachProgramsFAQ'sArticlesAbout Us

© 2026 Oak And Elephant Lab. All rights reserved.

CoachfulPowered by Coachful